Guha Krishnamurthi

88 Texas L. Rev. See Also 91

PDF Document

Responding to Professor Lee, Guha Krishnamurthi argues that Lee’s objections to the Bad Character, Notice, and Disobedience accounts are unpersuasive.  As a result, Krishnamurthi argues that Lee’s own account, Recidivism as Omission, does not have any of the advantages over the competing accounts that Lee claims it has.  He argues that there are further detractions to Recidivism as Omission that make it implausible and possibly redundant.  Finally, he contends that the Notice account best explains the intuition that the recidivist deserves more punishment.